The Rise of Pick 'N' Mix in the USA: Why It Offers So Much More Than You Think
Written byPoppin Candy
Pick and mix isn't new. Anyone who grew up in the UK remembers standing in front of a wall of plastic bins at Woolworths, paper bag in hand, loading up on cola bottles, foam shrimps and fizzy dummies. It was a ritual. A rite of passage, even. But in the US, that experience never really existed in the same way. American candy culture has always been about brands, packaging and individual bars. The idea of building your own mix from scratch just wasn't part of the landscape.
That's changed. And it's changed fast.
Pick and mix has taken off in the US in a way that few people predicted, driven by social media, a growing appetite for international candy, and a shift in what people actually want from their candy. It's not just about scooping candy into a bag anymore. It's about curation, personalisation and access to products that don't sit on any regular American shelf.
How Pick and Mix Went from British Nostalgia to US Obsession
The shift started on TikTok. Swedish candy haul videos, BUBS foam skull taste tests, and pick and mix packing clips started racking up millions of views over the last few years. Creators like Mary Grace Graves brought BUBS Swedish candy to a mainstream American audience, and the response was massive. The appeal wasn't just the candy themselves. It was the format. Watching someone build a custom bag, choosing every item, mixing textures and flavours, tapped into something that American candy aisles had never really offered.
The numbers back it up. Non-chocolate candy sales in the US grew by $5 billion between 2019 and 2024, a 70% jump driven largely by social media influence and a younger generation looking for something different. The US candy market itself is projected to be worth around $19 billion in 2026, with online stores growing at the fastest rate of any sales channel at 9.2% year on year. People aren't just buying more candy. They're buying it differently, and they're buying it online.
It's Not Just Candy in a Bag
The biggest misconception about pick and mix is that it's a simple concept. Choose some candy, put them in a bag, done. But modern pick and mix, especially the way it's done online, offers a level of choice and personalisation that traditional candy buying can't touch.
Take Poppin Candy's range as an example. You're not limited to a bag. You can build a custom bag, a bowl, a large bowl, a platter or a Snackle Box. Each format gives you a different amount of space and a different way to present your selection. The platter lays everything out for sharing. The Snackle Box sits somewhere between a gift and a personal stash. The bag is quick, easy and perfect for when you just want your favourites delivered without any fuss.
Then there's the range itself. Hundreds of individual candy to choose from, spanning Swedish foam candy, British classics, sour belts, chocolate boulders, liquorice, gummies, nougat, taffy and more. You're not picking from a small selection at a shop counter. You're browsing an entire catalogue and building something that's completely yours.
Swedish Candy Changed the Game
BUBS deserves its own section because it played a huge role in bringing pick and mix to the US mainstream. The Swedish foam candy brand became one of the most talked about confectionery products in America through TikTok alone. Sour Raspberry and Lemon Foam Skulls, Wild Strawberry and Pomegranate Foam Ovals, Dizzy Bubblegum Skulls. These products were completely unknown to most American consumers two years ago. Now they're some of the most requested items in online pick and mix.
What made BUBS land so well in the US is worth paying attention to. The texture is different to anything in the American candy aisle. Soft, foamy, light. The flavours are bold without being artificial. And a huge number of BUBS products are vegan, gluten free and halal friendly, which ticks boxes that a lot of mainstream American candy doesn't.
Swedish candy opened the door, but the range goes well beyond Scandinavia. British classics like Squashies, foam mushrooms and Strawberry and Cream Rocketz sit alongside Asian imports, American favourites and products from across Europe. The pick and mix format is the thing that ties it all together, giving customers access to candy from multiple countries in a single order.
Create Your Own Asia Candy & Snacks
More Than Just Candy: Drinks, Snacks and Full Hauls
One of the reasons pick and mix has grown so fast in the US is that the best online stores don't stop at candy. Poppin Candy's range extends into imported drinks, crisps and snacks, biscuits and cookies, cereals, chocolate and energy drinks. You can build an entire international snack haul in one order, mixing American classics with Japanese imports, Swedish foam candy with Korean sparkling drinks, sour belts with Samyang ramen.
This matters because it changes the shopping behaviour. You're not buying a single product. You're curating an experience. A movie night haul. A gift for someone. A party spread. A personal stash of things you can't find anywhere else. The pick and mix mindset, choosing exactly what you want and building something custom, extends across every category.
Mystery Boxes add another layer. If you don't want to choose everything yourself, a mystery box gives you a curated surprise of candy, chocolate, drinks and snacks. It's the opposite end of the spectrum from pick and mix, but it scratches the same itch: the excitement of discovery, the fun of variety, and the feeling that your candy order is an event rather than a transaction.
Dietary Options That Actually Deliver
Another area where online pick and mix outperforms traditional candy buying is dietary choice. Vegan, halal, gluten free and sugar free options are baked into the range rather than treated as an afterthought. At Poppin Candy, dietary icons are displayed under each sweet so you can filter and build a mix that fits your requirements without having to read the back of every packet.
This is a significant shift. The US candy market has historically been slow to cater to dietary needs beyond "sugar free." The fact that an online pick and mix store can offer dedicated vegan mixes, halal friendly boxes, gluten free selections and sugar free candy as standard says a lot about how far the format has come. You can build a fully vegan pick and mix bag from scratch, or grab a pre-made dietary mix if you'd rather not choose every item yourself.
Pick and Mix as a Gift (Not Just a Treat)
Gifting is one of the fastest growing use cases for pick and mix in the US. A custom Snackle Box or platter filled with someone's favourite candy feels more personal than a box of chocolates from a department store. Mystery Boxes work as surprise gifts because the recipient doesn't know what's inside until they open it. Even a simple pick and mix bag, chosen with someone specific in mind, carries more thought than a generic gift card.
Freeze dried candy Mystery Boxes are one of the most gifted items on Poppin Candy's site, and it's easy to see why. They're fun, different, and almost everyone who tries them ends up ordering more.
Candy Gifting Freeze Dried Candy
Why It Offers So Much More
The rise of pick and mix in the US isn't just a trend. It's a correction. For decades, American candy culture revolved around branded bars, seasonal bags and impulse buys at the checkout. The idea of building your own selection, choosing from hundreds of international options, and having it delivered to your door simply didn't exist as an accessible option.
Now it does. And it offers more than the old sweet shop model ever could. More choice. More formats. More countries represented. More dietary options. More ways to personalise, gift and share. The fact that you can sit on your phone, browse candy from Sweden, Japan, the UK, Canada and the US, pick exactly what you want, and have it arrive in days is something that would have been unthinkable even five years ago.
Online pick and mix hasn't just arrived in the US. It's rewritten how Americans think about buying candy. And it's only getting bigger.
Some of our favourites
Written byPoppin Candy
Hi, I’m Poppin Candy, Managing Director! I work closely with the team to support them through the delivering of our products. I also collaborate closely with our clients to ensure the candies they want are able to be delivered to the highest quality standards.
